SM sent me a .zip file of old photos from our high school days. in it were a few of our good friend SPS, who during our junior year was struck by a car and a passed away. i honestly haven’t even thought about her in a long time, but seeing those photos brought me straight back to that winter in my dorm room when i picked up my phone and heard the news. i don’t remember who was on the other end, but i do remember the stunned silence, the cry, the fetal position i crawled into, the ridiculous hope that if i somehow prayed hard enough that i could somehow send a shot of healing magic across thousands of miles that would bring her back to life.
SPS, SM, YF and i were the four members of a cheese pact, so named because it was so cheesy and mushy in sentiment. we didn’t have many tenets or rules by which to abide, but the ones we did have ensured that we’d celebrate life milestones together. we were to call each other on our birthdays and attend each others weddings, childbirths, and funerals, in that order. we were just graduating high school. we were young and naive. we didn’t understand mortality. the future, aging, marriage, children — these were all givens. absolutes. death was something that came later. much later.
the summer before she passed, we shared one beautiful, warm day eating lunch together because we interned at neighboring offices. hers was for a toy company and mine was for a foundation. the benches in madison square park were all taken by corporate suits so we claimed a clean, poo-free spot on the lawn.
while our friendship extended back to middle school, attending separate colleges created a slight chasm in the relationship. you know how college goes: out of sight, out of mind. small talk was a necessity. we had to get to know each other — these “new us’s” whose identities were shifting and were being shaped by new surroundings, friends, even partners. she told me about this guy she was dating, how he was an orthodox jew, the son of famous mystery novelists, a really great guy from LA. then she asked about my love life.
you have to understand that it was a really uncomfortable topic for me back then because i was still closeted. it was made even more uncomfortable because in high school, SPS and i could’ve been an item. that is IF a) i hadn’t been a coward or b) i was willing to lie through my teeth pretending to be straight — depending on how you look at it. i still don’t know if the feelings of attraction i had for her back then were real, hormonal, projected, or who-knows-what. point being, she was really someone i thought i could’ve dated and my definition of “date” back then meant “preparing for our future together. forever.”
anyway, i’m pretty sure i gave her the same excuse i gave everyone back then: that there was no one who interested me enough. that i really look for long-term companionship. that i was too busy with other stuff.
she knew. she knew the real reason why i wasn’t dating. i knew she knew because she presented the worst segue in history by starting to discuss her many gay friends at harvard and their great relationships and the freedom and happiness they found in coming out. she said all this without directly asking me if i were gay, but in her eyes — in her puppy-dog eyes that opened widely when she wanted something — she was demanding the truth from me.
i think i segued back into how difficult it is to find a good “match” (i excluded pronouns and gender-descriptors from all conversations about relationships). she gave me a disappointed look. we finished eating. we hugged goodbye. we went back to work. i must have returned to the office feeling really flustered, both from the heat of the day but especially from our conversation.
thankfully, this was not a defining moment in our friendship even though it was one of, if not, THE last interaction i had with her alone. when i remember her, i think about shakespeare, and dorr, and house parties, and english class, and backstage antics, etc. yet, our conversation that day revealed so much about her personality and character. if i were more mature then, i would have realized how brave she was to broach the subject. she was going out on a limb to make sure i knew who i was. she wanted me to be just as happy as her other gay friends (that simple, right?). if i were more brave, i’d have given her the answers she wanted.
i reflect on that conversation now and think, “what would SPS think about my relationship today?” i hope she’s smiling down and doing a little giddy tap dance routine.
